Recent shocking murder cases have reignited the discussion about whether those convicted are mad, simply evil, or something else.

The matter is not a simple one. Developments in neuropsychology using fMRI, genetics and psychometrics, indicate that those with certain personality disorders, not previously considered insane, have brain differences which make it difficult or impossible for them to understand the distress of others. Not all are violent offenders, and some are very successful law-abiding people.

If they are not insane in the traditional psychiatric sense, but do not possess the biological equipment to understand the impact of the harm they inflict, are they legally culpable for their crimes? How can the public be kept safe whilst not curtailing the freedom of those who might never offend? Should violent psychopaths be imprisoned, or detained in secure hospitals? Should prospective detention ever be used? Come and have your say.

Introduction by Beryl Hylton Downing

Come and join the discussion

You are warmly invited to join us at The Telegraph, Orchard Street, Newcastle Upon Tyne NE1 3NY (behind the Central Station), for our next meeting on Tuesday 4th November

See here for location.